• Home
  • News
  • EC replies to the parliamentary question

EC replies to the parliamentary question

Commissioner Sinkevičius answered the question from MEP Zdechovský re. Turów mine

On 31 January 2020 Czech MEP Tomáš Zdechovský filed the following parliamentary question:

Subject: Infringement of EU environmental law by Poland

"The Turów coal mine is located on the Czech-Polish-German border. Mining was set to come to an end by 30 April 2020. However, the mine operator PGE GIEK S.A. has decided to extend production until 2044, covering 30 km2 and going 330 metres below ground level. Mining activity will have a demonstrably negative impact on the source of drinking water for approximately 30 000 inhabitants in the Czech Republic. In 2019, a transboundary impact assessment was conducted in accordance with the ESPOO Convention, in which the Czech Republic issued a negative opinion regarding the impact of continued mining at the Turów Mine. Nevertheless, in January 2020, the Regional Director of Nature Conservation in Wrocław issued a decision on environmental conditions for the project to continue mining the Turów coal deposit in which he gave his approval for the continuation of mining. In relation to EU law, there has been a violation of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, namely Articles 16, 37 and 41, a violation of Article 191 TFEU, a violation of the principle of sincere cooperation enshrined in the TEU, a failure to respect Directive 92/43/EEC on the protection of animals and plants, and a violation of Directive 2000/60/EC establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy.

Given this action, the disregarding of the Czech Republic’s position and the environmental impact assessment, and the violation of EU law, is the Commission monitoring this issue, and will it take active steps in this matter?"

The question is available on the European Parliament's website.


On 24 March 2020 Commissioner Virginijus Sinkevičius replied on behalf of the European Commission:

"As the Commission pointed out in its reply to Written Question E -003916/2019 , the primary responsibility for authorising projects and correctly implementing EC law lies with the public authorities of the Member States and if necessary may involve intervention by the courts.

It is therefore in the first place for the competent Polish authorities to apply the EC law in specific situations and for the relevant economic operators to comply with the obligations defined by the EU rules. At the same time, the Commission stands ready to take swift action where needed.

Regarding the case of the Turów lignite mine, it should be noted that even if the environmental decision has been taken, the development consent decision authorising the prolongation of the Turów lignite mine operation has not been issued yet because the deliberations of the competent authorities have not yet been concluded. According to the information available, Czech environmental organisations were allowed to appeal against the extension of the mine.

Yet, the Commission closely follows up the developments related to this case, including based on information from complaints received. In this respect, on 24 February 2020 the Commission launched an EU Pilot in order to assess the compliance with the obligations resulting from EU environmental law."

The answer is available on the European Parliament's website.


4 days before the answer was published, PGE was granted the prolongation of the mining licence for the Turów mine.







Popular Articles

04 June 2021

Why are you burning our future?

The storm surrounding Turów is going on, but Polska Grupa Energetyczna appears to be blind and deaf to the voices from Europe. While in the European Court of Justice the further fate of the ...
29 April 2021

PGE myths vs reality

In late April 2021 Polish Energy Group (PGE), the owner of the Turów mine launched an aggressive campaign "Green Deal, not a predatory transformation". PGE bought a number of spons...
22 March 2020

Thirst for justice: communities take on coal giant for stealing their water

Where Poland, Czechia and Germany meet, a thirsty coal mine threatens to leave 30,000 people without water but local communities are not giving in. Author: Roberta Arbinolo Published by META - th...

About Us

Our organizations jointly counteract the expansion of the open-cast Turów lignite mine in Poland for the benefit of local communities, nature and climate. We support civic activities undertaken by the international community at the interface of the Czech Republic, Germany and Poland. We strive to make the lignite-dependent Bogatynia enter the path of energy transition as well as economic and social transformation.

Fundacja Rozwój TAK Odkrywki NIE | This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.